Comments on: What Is The Optimal Size For A City? https://inditales.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/ Travel Blog from India Mon, 17 Apr 2023 06:27:43 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.1 By: Anuradha Goyal https://inditales.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-5738 Wed, 09 Sep 2015 08:51:02 +0000 http://www.travelgaon.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-5738 In reply to richa singh.

Richa, I think I found my answer in Goa – where I presently live 🙂

]]>
By: richa singh https://inditales.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-5692 Thu, 03 Sep 2015 08:25:26 +0000 http://www.travelgaon.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-5692 Well that does seem like the ideal place to find no? I would say somehow from my own experience Pune comes quite close. The pace is average population isn’t plenty and infra is very much suitable.

]]>
By: V https://inditales.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2166 Sat, 17 Sep 2005 18:24:00 +0000 http://www.travelgaon.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2166 Well you should not be complaining 🙂

Top 100 Cities of the World – ranked by population

NOTE: Numbers shown include population within the recognized metro area
of the city, and they include
people living in the immediate surrounding area outside of the
established border of the city.

1. Tokyo, Japan – 28,025,000
2. Mexico City, Mexico – 18,131,000
3. Mumbai, India – 18,042,000
4. Sáo Paulo, Brazil – 17, 711,000
5. New York City, USA – 16,626,000
6. Shanghai, China – 14,173,000
7. Lagos, Nigeria – 13,488,000
8. Los Angeles, USA – 13,129,000
9. Calcutta, India – 12,900,000
10. Buenos Aires, Argentina – 12,431,000

11. Seóul, South Korea – 12,215,000
12. Beijing, China – 12,033,000
13. Karachi, Pakistan – 11,774,000
14. Delhi, India – 11,680,000
15. Dhaka, Bangladesh – 10,979,000
16. Manila, Philippines – 10,818,000
17. Cairo, Egypt – 10,772,000
18. Õsaka, Japan – 10,609,000
19. Rio de Janeiro, Brazil – 10,556,000
20. Tianjin, China – 10,239,000

21. Jakarta, Indonesia – 9,815,000
22. Paris, France – 9,638,000
23. Istanbul, Turkey – 9,413,000
24. Moscow, Russian Fed. – 9,299,000
25. London, United Kingdom – 7,640,000
26. Lima, Peru – 7,443,000
27. Tehrãn, Iran – 7,380,000
28. Bangkok, Thailand – 7,221,000
29. Chicago, USA – 6,945,000
30. Bogotá, Colombia – 6,834,000

31. Hyderabad, India – 6,833,000
32. Chennai, India – 6,639,000
33. Essen, Germany – 6,559,000
34. Hangzhou, China – 6,389,000
35. Hong Kong, China – 6,097,000
36. Lahore, Pakistan – 6,030,000
37. Shenyang, China – 5,681,000
38. Changchun, China – 5,566,000
39. Bangalore, India – 5,544,000
40. Harbin, China – 5,475,000

41. Chengdu, China – 5,293,000
42. Santiago, Chile – 5,261,000
43. Guangzhou, China – 5,162,000
44. St. Petersburg, Russian Fed. – 5,132,000
45. Kinshasa, DRC – 5,068,000
46. Baghdãd, Iraq – 4,796,000
47. Jinan, China – 4,789,000
48. Wuhan, China – 4,750,000
49. Toronto, Canada – 4,657,000
50. Yangon, Myanmar (Burma) – 4,458,000

51. Alger, Algeria – 4,447,000
52. Philadelphia, USA – 4,398,000
53. Qingdao, China – 4,376,000
54. Milano, Italy – 4,251,000
55. Pusan, South Korea – 4,239,000
56. Belo Horizonte, Brazil – 4,160,000
57. Almadabad, India – 4,154,000
58. Madrid, Spain – 4,072,000
59. San Francisco, USA – 4,051,000
60. Alexandria, Egypt – 3,995,000

61. Washington DC, USA – 3,927,000
62. Houston, USA – 3,918,000
63. Dallas, USA – 3,912,000
64. Guadalajara, Mexico – 3,908,000
65. Chongging, China – 3,896,000
66. Medellin, Colombia – 3,831,000
67. Detroit, USA – 3,785,000
68. Handan, China – 3,763,000
69. Frankfurt, Germany – 3,700,000
70. Porto Alegre, Brazil – 3,699,000

71. Hanoi, Vietnam – 3,678,000
72. Sydney, Australia – 3,665,000
73. Santo Domingo, Dom. Rep. – 3,601,000
74. Singapore, Singapore – 3,587,000
75. Casablanca, Morocco – 3,535,000
76. Katowice, Poland – 3,488,000
77. Pune, India – 3,485,000
78. Bangdung, Indonesia – 3,420,000
79. Monterrey, Mexico – 3,416,000
80. Montréal, Canada – 3,401,000

81. Nagoya, Japan – 3,377,000
82. Nanjing, China – 3,375,000
83. Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire – 3,359,000
84. Xi’an, China – 3,352,000
85. Berlin, Germany – 3,337,000
86. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia – 3,328,000
87. Recife, Brazil – 3,307,000
88. Dusseldorf, Germany – 3,251,000
89. Ankara, Turkey – 3,190,000
90. Melbourne, Australia – 3,188,000

91. Salvador, Brazil – 3,180,000
92. Dalian, China – 3,153,000
93. Caracas, Venezuela – 3,153,000
94. Adis Abeba, Ethiopia – 3,112,000
95. Athina, Greece – 3,103,000
96. Cape Town, South Africa – 3,092,000
97. Koln, Germany – 3.067,000
98. Maputo, Mozambique – 3,017,000
99. Napoli, Italy – 3,012,000
100. Fortaleza, Brazil – 3,007,000

]]>
By: Sujit https://inditales.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2165 Sat, 17 Sep 2005 07:02:00 +0000 http://www.travelgaon.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2165 Well its true that we dream of a city that can provide all the facilities. And chandigrah is supposed to be the only planned city in the country .. and the planning was done so well that for the next few decades the authorities need not worry about the infrastructure part. However bangalore on the contratry was not planned.. it was supposed to be a pensioners grand place. So, the planning mostly meant to adhoc, just like BCC does, repair patch work.

Just thinking about the question in the reverse direction. Given the current situation of the way in which the population of everthying is increasing except greenary where it is decreasing, its important what can be thought to de-congest?.. Can we as individuals come up with some solutions?.. We love to live her.. but can we do to the city? …!! something ponder about!!

]]>
By: perspective https://inditales.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2164 Fri, 16 Sep 2005 08:52:00 +0000 http://www.travelgaon.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2164 I can think of one … Baroda/Vadodara… where i was brought up…
Its close to a city called Bharuch and ankleshwar and lots of people work in these cities..and come back to Baroda everyday.

You can travel across the city in 30 min highest… and all points of the city are accessible..

This is answering your query…
I’d say you could’ve easily been a part of the Planning Commission… I dream of that too… to be able to plan India better…
But you have no ideas of all the factors that hold back such plans and ideas… India is far too old a country with many determinants existing already!

]]>
By: accesssri https://inditales.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2163 Fri, 16 Sep 2005 04:29:00 +0000 http://www.travelgaon.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2163 Good thought Anuradha! Every day while travelling to work and back the thought which occurs to me a million no of times is why can’t other district headquarters be developed into smaller and decent cities and why the Government is allowing so many companies to set up their shops in Bangalore, even when the companies themselves are looking for secondary cities to spread out.
Hope one day, our Government will learn the concept of Pro-active thinking rather than digging up the well, when the fire has been caught.

]]>
By: Jayesh https://inditales.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2162 Fri, 16 Sep 2005 02:16:00 +0000 http://www.travelgaon.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2162 There is nothing like optimal size.The rise of Bangalore just happened in a short span of 3 years where almost every IT and BPO MNC set shop there. And due to its weather and location in the country, people across India migrated to it. But the city was not ready for it.
The reverse is happening in Hyderabad. The city was all ready but there are so many office spaces going empty. The demand was below supply.
Mumbai is a perennial problem due to the linear nature of the city and snob value attached to being in South Mumbai. Plus Mumbai is always starved of funds by Delhi which keeps expanding radially into Noida, Ghaziabad and Gurgaon.

]]>
By: Anuradha https://inditales.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2161 Wed, 14 Sep 2005 03:51:00 +0000 http://www.travelgaon.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2161 Anonymous, I have lived in Chandigarh for most of my life, so I am sure somewhere I was looking for that kind of a city only. But since its been almost 10 years that I am out of that city, and I don;t know how it has grown in these years, I did not mention it. But yes, that may be the city closest to a dream city.

Shivaji, Bay area is a good example of distributes cities, but again I have always visited that area, never really lived there.

Samba, looks like you have always lived in a big cities. Small cities are equally good if not better, its just that when you live in big city, you start thinking that no other city has these facilities. I have different views on rural consumerism, will writw about that sometime.

Parth, we all find out the ways to utilize this time, but would you really like to spend time that way, specially in India where driving is not as much a pleasure, at least within the city limits of any big city.

Thanks for writing in guys…I am thinking loud, but can we do something to have smaller well developed places, rather than a 1 Billion+ population trying to run to 5-7 major cities.

-Anu

]]>
By: Karthik L G https://inditales.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2160 Tue, 13 Sep 2005 17:11:00 +0000 http://www.travelgaon.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2160 good old bengalooru was just the way how u want ur ideal city to be

but due to influx of ppl from all over and due to this dirty it/bpo industry it has become the way it is now

]]>
By: Shivaji https://inditales.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2159 Tue, 13 Sep 2005 09:49:00 +0000 http://www.travelgaon.com/what-is-the-optimal-size-for-a-city/#comment-2159 interesting post….
I guess it’s possible to have a larger city if facilities (schools, hospitals, offices, airports etc) are well distributed…
I have lived in the Bay area and there cities like Palo Alto, Mountain View etc. are as large as say Andheri, Goregaon… At the two ends of the area are San Francisco and San Jose with the large airports…most offices are well spread.. but the cultural heart obviously lies in Frisco

]]>